Image
Close up image of a globe with a blurred background
Blog

Quality Measurement Has to Work in the Real World

Summary

  • Quality measures work best when they reflect the realities of care. Nephrologist Jeffrey Silberzweig shares how clinician and patient perspectives can help ensure that measurement leads to meaningful improvement.

About 30 years ago, while making rounds in a dialysis clinic, Dr. Jeffrey Silberzweig met a patient whose words have stayed with him throughout his career.

“Until you sit in one of these chairs, you don’t really understand what it’s like to not feel well.”

For Dr. Silberzweig — a practicing nephrologist, Chief Medical Officer of The Rogosin Institute, and professor at Weill Cornell Medical College — the comment is an important reminder: quality measurement is not ultimately about collecting data or evaluating performance. Measures developed at the national level affect care in very real ways for patients and clinicians. At their best, they help drive meaningful improvements in care.

That perspective is what he brings to Battelle’s Partnership for Quality Measurement® (PQM). As a PQM committee member, Dr. Silberzweig works alongside clinicians, patients, caregivers, researchers, health systems, payers, and other stakeholders to evaluate measures that may be used to assess and improve healthcare quality nationwide.

Bringing Clinical Reality to Measure Review

During a recent PQM review cycle, committee members considered measures for the End-Stage Renal Disease Quality Incentive Program, including Facility-Level Percentage of Chronic Hyperphosphatemia in Dialysis Patients.

Hyperphosphatemia — elevated phosphorus levels in people receiving dialysis — is associated with increased risks of hospitalization, cardiovascular disease, and mortality among people with kidney disease. Addressing it is clinically important. At the same time, committee members considered whether the proposed measure had been sufficiently tested in the dialysis population and how its use could affect patients and care teams.

For Dr. Silberzweig, this is the essential work of quality measurement: weighing a measure’s potential value alongside the evidence, feasibility, and possible unintended consequences. 

“Being involved gives us the opportunity to ensure that collecting data for quality measurement is not overly burdensome for patients or providers while still producing meaningful measures that drive improvement,” he said.

Rather than treating review as a simple yes-or-no decision, committee members consider whether a measure is scientifically sound, clinically meaningful, feasible to implement, and likely to advance better care. They also consider whether it should be monitored and revisited as new evidence and implementation experience emerge.

Looking Beyond Performance Metrics

Through his participation in PQM, Dr. Silberzweig has gained a broader perspective on how quality measures influence care. Beyond performance reporting, he has seen how measures shape clinical workflows, organizational priorities, payment programs, and patient experiences.

“Participating in PQM has given me a better understanding of how quality measures are developed, why they matter, and how they influence the care that I provide to my patients.”

The experience did more than deepen his understanding of measurement. It also informed how he approaches improvement in his own practice. 

“The care that I’m able to provide at the individual patient level and at the level of a provider organization has improved by participating.”

For example, phosphorus management requires care teams to consider whether patients can access and adhere to treatment. Following a Medicare policy update that allowed his facility to dispense medications used to manage high phosphorus levels directly, the team could more easily monitor treatment response and adjust therapy when needed. For patients receiving dialysis, this can make treatment more accessible and care more coordinated.

Why Clinician Voices Matter

Quality measures can affect care processes, resource allocation, reimbursement, and patient experiences. Clinicians bring firsthand knowledge of the conditions and treatments being measured, the realities of implementation in busy care settings, and potential unintended consequences that may not be evident from data alone.

But clinicians are only one essential voice. Dr. Silberzweig emphasizes that the strongest measures also reflect input from patients, families, caregivers, providers, payers, and other stakeholders.

People receiving dialysis and other forms of intensive treatment understand the daily realities of care in ways that data alone cannot capture. Their perspectives help keep quality measurement focused on what matters most: better outcomes and a better experience of care.

An Opportunity to Help Shape Better Care

For clinicians interested in contributing beyond their own organizations, Dr. Silberzweig sees PQM participation as a meaningful opportunity to help shape measures before they affect care more broadly.

“Joining PQM is a worthwhile investment that can improve patient care,” he said. 

PQM brings together people with different perspectives around a shared purpose: ensuring that quality measurement improves care for people. For Dr. Silberzweig, that begins with listening to patients and asking a fundamental question of every measure: Will it work in the real world of clinical practice?

Jeffrey Silberzweig, MD, is a nephrologist and Chief Medical Officer of The Rogosin Institute, where he oversees the quality and cost of care for dialysis services. He is a Professor of Clinical Medicine at Weill Cornell Medical College, where he contributes to the education of future generations of physicians.

Kaely Burgess is a Project Manager, Amy Minichino is a Project Manager, and Tara Bristol Rouse is a Senior Project Director at IHI.

Learn More

Battelle is a CMS-certified consensus-based entity and administers the Partnership for Quality Measurement® (PQM). To get involved:

All committee and membership opportunities are free of charge. Questions? Contact PQM at PQMSupport@battelle.org.

Photo by wirestock

You may also be interested in:

Share